THE APEX TIMES
John Tooson gets two life sentences in Boyd Circuit Court for 2022 murders of two Kentucky sisters
Attorney General Russell Coleman announced that the 36-year-old Ohio man received separate life terms in connection with the 2022 deaths of Selina Easter and Summer Algarakhuly.
John Tooson, 36, was sentenced to two life terms in Boyd Circuit Court for the 2022 murders of two Kentucky sisters, Attorney General Russell Coleman said in an announcement made on June 29, 2026. The court imposed separate life sentences tied to the deaths of Selina Easter and Summer Algarakhuly.
The case was prosecuted in Kentucky and concluded with a sentencing order in Boyd Circuit Court, where the judge imposed the life terms after the convictions were reached in the earlier phases of the proceedings. Coleman’s office said the sentences were for the 2022 killings of the two young sisters.
Coleman did not describe in the announcement the sentence length beyond the life terms, nor did the statement provide additional details such as trial dates, evidentiary issues, or whether either sentence includes any additional time. The announcement also did not outline the defense arguments or the prosecution’s specific sentencing recommendations beyond the fact that the court imposed two life sentences.
Family members and the community have been affected by the deaths of Easter and Algarakhuly, whose murders generated significant attention given that they were sisters and that the case involved a Kentucky prosecution. In the period leading up to sentencing, the state’s efforts focused on holding accountable the person charged in connection with the 2022 double homicide.
Attorney General Coleman’s office framed the outcome as a closure through the court process, with the two life sentences reflecting the separate statutory and factual basis the prosecution pursued for each victim. Sentencing in criminal cases like this is the culmination of a structured process that begins with charges, continues through trial proceedings, and ends with the court’s imposition of punishment consistent with Kentucky law.
With the life sentences now issued, the next steps in the case would generally involve post-judgment options available to the convicted defendant under Kentucky and federal law, including potential appeals or other review processes. Until any such review occurs, Tooson remains under the sentences as ordered by the Boyd Circuit Court.
Why It Matters
- The ruling underscores the finality of sentencing after a Kentucky prosecution for crimes committed in 2022, with the court imposing two separate life terms for two victims.
- The outcome closes a major public-safety chapter for the families of Easter and Algarakhuly, with the punishment now set by the court rather than remaining pending through ongoing proceedings.
- For Kentucky’s criminal justice system, the case illustrates continued prosecution and sentencing for homicide cases that may involve defendants from outside the state.
- The announcement sets a clear procedural milestone, with post-judgment review options the remaining avenue for the defendant if pursued.
Key Facts
- John Tooson, 36, received two life sentences in Boyd Circuit Court.
- The sentences were imposed for the 2022 murders of Kentucky sisters Selina Easter and Summer Algarakhuly.
- Attorney General Russell Coleman announced the sentencing outcome.
- The case resulted in separate life terms associated with each victim.