When did Josh Allen become “the one” for Bills fans? A look back at the 2020 turning point

Josh Allen has been described as one of the NFL’s elite quarterbacks for years, and the Buffalo Bills’ franchise quarterback has backed up that label with sustained production and league-wide recognition. In a recent reflection published July 6, Yahoo Sports writer Chris Trapasso posed a simple question for fans: when did the realization hit that Allen was not merely a contender in Buffalo, but the clear standard-bearer. The piece points to a moment that, in hindsight, feels like proof that Allen’s best traits showed up even when the Bills were not yet fully past their postseason frustrations.

The recollection travels back to the Bills’ 2020 season, during the stretch in which Buffalo finally won the AFC East for the first time in a quarter-century. A specific home game from that run, against the Los Angeles Rams in late September, becomes the centerpiece of the author’s “when it clicked” theory. Buffalo raced out to a 21-3 lead at halftime, and the offense looked in control through a series of sharp, decisive throws, including an Allen-to-Stefon Diggs touchdown connection that pushed the Bills to 28-3 in the third quarter.

But the same game also delivered the kind of lesson Bills fans had learned to fear. After taking a 28-3 advantage, Buffalo “squandered that lead,” according to the account, and was ultimately outscored 29-0. That turnaround matters because it places Allen’s performance inside a difficult emotional frame. The author’s point is not that the Bills avoided failure, but that Allen still found answers while the scoreboard swung against them.

On the Bills’ last possession of that contest, the reflection highlights a critical third down: Allen faced 3rd-and-22 from his own 31-yard line. The writer describes a moment when the expectation was that the pass would fall short or gain far less than the distance needed. Instead, Allen stood in the pocket, scanned the field, and connected with Cole Beasley over the middle for enough yards after the catch to move the chains. The emphasis is on the decision-making under pressure, not on a highlight-reel escape.

The throughline in the reflection is that this was different from what the Bills had previously seen from the quarterback position in similar high-leverage situations. After Buffalo had lost momentum the hard way, Allen still executed a play that converted a long, punishing down. In the author’s view, it was precisely the type of “unexpected” competence that builds trust, and that, for many fans, is where “the one” realization begins.

For the Bills, the significance of returning to 2020 is that it captures both the promise and the unfinished business of Allen’s early peak. Yahoo Sports’ framing also underscores how uncommon Allen’s individual resume has been among active quarterbacks, noting his MVP and additional MVP-vote seasons, and contrasting that with what the author says no other currently active passer can match. Whether fans point to one play or a growing set of moments, the 2020 sequence is presented as a bridge between raw brilliance and repeatable leadership.

What to watch next is less about defining Allen’s legacy and more about whether the Bills can convert that kind of quarterbacking into postseason outcomes that change the franchise’s narrative. The “when did you realize” question is ultimately about belief, but it ends at the same place every Bills run ends: can Buffalo take the confidence that’s built in moments like 3rd-and-22 and turn it into a championship-level finish? The answer, as always, is revealed when the pressure becomes real again.

{